Professor Ed Cairns,
University of Ulster, Ireland
After generations of bitter quarrels, how can victims of violent
acts see members of the opposing group as worthy of forgiveness?
This study seeks to identify barriers to forgiveness and to reveal
how these barriers can be overcome.
Northern Ireland has
been in the grip of bitter sectarian violence for over a quarter
of a century. With a fragile peace finally at hand, what will make
it possible for victims and aggressors to pass each other on the
streets each day? Could forgiveness help reconcile life-long enemies
in this war-torn corner of the world?
These are just some
of the questions that Professor Ed Cairns, a psychologist from Ulster
University, will address in his landmark research on intergroup
conflict and forgiveness in Northern Ireland.
"Political peace does
not mean there will be peace in the hearts of the victims," says
Cairns. "To move on, we must deal with the past -- because sleeping
dogs never lie." Cairns points to the Balkans as an example of a
region where age-old animosities have returned to haunt a new generation.
Working with victims
from different factions, Cairns is conducting what he calls "the
first extensive theoretical and empirical study of intergroup forgiveness."
Building on the work of British social psychologist and identity
theorist Henri Tajfl, Cairns' study is based on the premise that
we are more likely to forgive violent acts perpetrated by members
of our own religious, ethnic or political "groups."
Cairns has already held
focus groups to test attitudes towards forgiveness with Protestant,
Catholic, and mixed groups. Next, after conducting a random survey
that explores respondents' identity as victims or aggressors, their
sense of group affiliation, and their attitudes towards other groups,
Cairns will recruit paid volunteers to take part in a series of
studies that explore social identity and forgiveness. Cairns will
ask participants, for example, to take part in workshops where they
imagine that the person who hurt them was a member of their own
social group, or of their family. By isolating key variables and
evaluating a range of intervention techniques, Cairns hopes to shed
light on any barriers to forgiveness that are characteristic of
intergroup conflict -- and on how individuals and communities can
begin to take those barriers down.
Despite his hopes, Cairns
has no illusions that forgiveness is a panacea.
"Is it ethical to ask
people if they'll forgive and does this imply that people 'should'
forgive?" he asks. "The assumption is that deep down everyone would
like to forgive but in fact many people don't want to -- especially
in Northern Ireland where the wounds run deep." Preliminary focus
group data indicate that many Northern Irish -- Protestants, Catholics,
Unionists and Republicans alike -- prefer to hold on to, rather
than forgive, the past.
Yet, as the country
crawls towards peace, Cairns clings to the belief that for some,
his work will help ease the pain caused by decades of the 'Troubles.'
"I never thought I 'd reach a day where I could think about forgiveness
in Northern Ireland," says Cairns. "But here I am."
Dr. Ed Cairns is
Professor of Psychology in the School of Psychology and Communication
Sciences at the University of Ulster in Coleraine, Northern Ireland
He is a Fellow of the British Psychological Society and is associated
with the Division of Peace Psychology of the American Psychological
Association. His most recent book is Children and Political Violence,
published by Blackwell in 1996.
More: